Bibliographic Services Division (BSD)
Frequently Asked Questions about Indexing for MEDLINE
- How is MEDLINE® produced?
- Do you scan in the citations?
- As an author, how should I select keywords so that my article is retrieved in MEDLINE?
- What types of articles are selected to be indexed?
- What is a Publication Type? How does it differ from descriptors?
- Can NLM add recently adopted new terminology to my article published several years ago?
- What online journals are indexed for MEDLINE? What journals have online versions?
Employment Opportunities as an Indexer for MEDLINE
- Who are the indexers, and what are their qualifications?
- How can I become an indexer?
- I've heard that I can do indexing work at home. How do I apply for this type of position?
- How can I apply for a job as an abstract writer for MEDLINE?
- How can I apply for a job as a translator with the Index Section?
MEDLINE is the product of many information specialists at the National Library of Medicine: serials librarians who obtain journal subscriptions and check in the individual journal issues; data review specialists who assure the quality of all supplied and created bibliographic citations; biomedical subject specialists who analyze the subject content of articles and index the concepts that are discussed, using the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) controlled vocabulary; and computer and information specialists who develop and maintain the various systems, including the retrieval system. Every journal issue and article cited in MEDLINE has been reviewed and inspected by many individuals.
Bibliographic citations in MEDLINE are currently created by two different methods. Many journal publishers supply NLM with citation and abstract data electronically, tagged with XML (Extensible Markup Language) codes to identify different data elements. Article citations from print journals for which data are not supplied are created with a combination of optical character recognition (OCR) and keystroking. Citations that are received electronically may still require a considerable amount of human intervention to add supplementary data and to make other data uniform.
The National Library of Medicine does not use author-assigned keywords for MEDLINE indexing. The terms that are used are descriptors from MeSH (Medical Subject Headings) – the National Library of Medicine’s controlled vocabulary thesaurus. MESH includes more than 27,000 descriptors, most of which may be qualified with one or more of over 80 MeSH subheadings. In addition, indexed terms may be derived from the more than 200,000 headings called Supplementary Concept Records (SCRs); these records (representing chemicals and rare diseases) exist within a separate thesaurus and are mapped to MESH descriptors. NLM’s policy for indexing is to use the most specific terms possible which best describe the content and substance of the indexed item.
Since early 2013, PubMed has displayed publisher-supplied keywords in the KEYWORDS field of the abstract display. Authors who wish to supply those keywords using the MeSH vocabulary can consult the MeSH Browser (available at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/MBrowser.html). They may also use a tool called MeSH on Demand (available at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/MeSHonDemand.html) that identifies MeSH terms in text using the NLM Medical Text Indexer program. After processing the text, MeSH on Demand returns a list of MeSH terms relevant to the text that was input.
If authors wish their articles to be retrieved by their preferred terminology, they should ensure that these words appear in the title or abstract, where they will be searchable as text words.
NLM indexes only the substantive content of journals selected for MEDLINE indexing. In journals selected for cover-to-cover indexing, for instance, NLM does not index items such as book reviews or abstracts.
Furthermore, a number of journals are multidisciplinary and publish articles about non-life science fields such as astronomy, geology, mathematics, and the like. Other journals cover many aspects of a subject field, including non-life science aspects (e.g., chemical journals may contain articles about physical chemistry as well as biochemistry). Because NLM indexes only articles that pertain to the life sciences, articles in these selectively indexed journals that do not pertain in any way to the life sciences are considered “out of scope” and appear as unindexed citations in PubMed.
Since 1991, Publication Types (PTs) have been assigned by NLM indexers to describe the form of presentation of materials that are indexed. Some PTs reflect the format and editorial practices of the individual journal; others reflect the indexer's analytical judgment. Items indexed prior to 1991 have had a limited number of PTs added by machine rather than by re-indexing.
PTs such as "letter" or "editorial" are determined by the style or section heading used by the journal. "Letter" is assigned to routine letters to the editor as well as to lengthier articles if the journal labels them as "scientific correspondence" or similar caption. Likewise, some journals label lead articles as "editorial," while others reserve this caption for expressions of opinion. NLM follows the journal's practice and assigns the PT "editorial" rather than "journal article" in both these cases. A "classical article" is one that has been reprinted by a journal because of its significance; NLM makes no independent determination of an article's "classical" status.
A published item may be assigned more than one PT. The default PT is "journal article"; however, a journal article may also be a "review" or a "randomized controlled trial." Certain PTs never co-occur. For instance, an item cannot be both a journal article and letter, editorial, or news item.
PTs should not be confused with Main Headings (MHs) or descriptors, although many PTs have a corresponding MH. PTs describe the form of an article; MHs describe its contents.
NLM does not re-index articles as new terms are added to the MeSH vocabulary. New terms are transparently linked to existing terms as they are added so that searchers using the new terms will retrieve the older citations.
Electronic, or online, journals come in two basic types: journals that are online only and those that are published both in online and print formats. Of the latter, many titles have identical content in both formats; some have content unique to the electronic medium. The ISSN that displays on the MEDLINE citation reflects the version of the title from which NLM indexes the issue (print or online). Currently, about 81% of journals indexed for MEDLINE are indexed from the online version; a list of these journals is available at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/journals/online.html.
Most MEDLINE indexers are either Federal employees or employees of firms that have contracts with NLM for biomedical indexing. A prospective indexer must have no less than a bachelor's degree in a biomedical science. A reading knowledge of certain modern foreign languages is typically sought. An increasing number of recent recruits hold advanced degrees in biomedical sciences. Federal employees must be United States citizens, but citizenship is not mandatory for contractors.
Indexers are trained in principles of MEDLINE indexing, using the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) controlled vocabulary as part of individualized training. The initial part of the training is based on an online training module (partially available to the public at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/indexing/index.html), followed by a period of practice indexing. NLM does not accept other indexing training programs as a substitute.
About 1% of MEDLINE indexing is performed by indexers at the International MEDLARS Centers in Sweden and Brazil.
Indexing vacancies at the National Library of Medicine are filled competitively. Any such vacancy is listed on NLM's Web site. Indexers generally are classified as Technical Information Specialists, in the GS-1412 job series. The normal career ladder goes from GS-9 to GS-12.
For information about applying for work as an indexer with NLM's contractors, please contact the Index Section for a listing of all firms with a current indexing contract.
Contract indexers work from their homes once their training has been completed. Indexers who are Federal employees may qualify to telework for two or three days each week under the NIH Telework Program. See the preceding paragraph for information on applying for either type of indexing position.
No original abstracts are created for MEDLINE. Author abstracts in English published in a journal are input for MEDLINE.
Although journals from many languages are represented in MEDLINE, the National Library of Medicine does not translate the articles. Indexers who perform subject analysis of the articles typically have a reading knowledge of scientific terminology in one or more foreign languages. They read and comprehend the articles, but they do not need to translate them in order to index them.