NLM logo

Gallery: True Account

John P. Phair: A Complete History of Vermont’s Celebrated Murder Case..., 1879

John P. Phair: A complete history of Vermont's celebrated murder case: Containing a report of the trial and conviction for the murder of Ann E. Freeze, at Rutland, the hearing on exceptions, the sentence, "dying statement," two reprieves, legislative proceedings, petitions for new trial, and final effort to stay execution. Compiled from the stenographer's report and official records, by E.C. Carrigan. 112 pp. (Boston, 1879).

About the Case
In June 1874, firemen putting out a blaze at a house in Rutland, Vermont discovered the body of Ann Freeze, a 27-year-old sex worker. Freeze’s throat had been cut, her body had several stab wounds, and her jewelry was missing. Suspicion fell on John P. Phair, a handsome young mechanic with a criminal record, who had been Freeze’s lover. Read more….