NLM logo

Gallery: WEAPON

The Provocation and the Reply; or Allopathy Versus Physio-Medicalism in a Review of Prof. M.B. Wright's Remarks at the Dedication of the Cincinnati New Hospital, January 8th, 1869, Alva Curtis, Cincinnati, 1870

The title page of this 19th-century medical tract captures the professional tensions, antagonisms, and rivalries typical of the period. The author, Alva Curtis (1797-1881), was a founder of the "physio-medicalist" school. He is responding to the "provocation" he detected in the remarks earlier delivered by a member of the "allopathic" school. The physio-medicalists, like the Thomsonians from whom they derived, relied largely on botanic ingredients in their ministrations, whereas the allopaths included metallic compounds in their often quite vigorous pharmaceutical preparations.

View in NLM Digital Collections